xnu-2782.30.5.tar.gz

[apple/xnu.git] / osfmk / ipc / ipc_importance.c

/*
 * Copyright (c) 2013 Apple Inc. All rights reserved.
 *
 * @APPLE_OSREFERENCE_LICENSE_HEADER_START@
 *
 * This file contains Original Code and/or Modifications of Original Code
 * as defined in and that are subject to the Apple Public Source License
 * Version 2.0 (the 'License'). You may not use this file except in
 * compliance with the License. The rights granted to you under the License
 * may not be used to create, or enable the creation or redistribution of,
 * unlawful or unlicensed copies of an Apple operating system, or to
 * circumvent, violate, or enable the circumvention or violation of, any
 * terms of an Apple operating system software license agreement.
 *
 * Please obtain a copy of the License at
 * http://www.opensource.apple.com/apsl/ and read it before using this file.
 *
 * The Original Code and all software distributed under the License are
 * distributed on an 'AS IS' basis, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EITHER
 * EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AND APPLE HEREBY DISCLAIMS ALL SUCH WARRANTIES,
 * INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
 * FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, QUIET ENJOYMENT OR NON-INFRINGEMENT.
 * Please see the License for the specific language governing rights and
 * limitations under the License.
 *
 * @APPLE_OSREFERENCE_LICENSE_HEADER_END@
 */

#include <mach/mach_types.h>
#include <mach/notify.h>
#include <ipc/ipc_types.h>
#include <ipc/ipc_importance.h>
#include <ipc/ipc_port.h>
#include <ipc/ipc_voucher.h>
#include <kern/ipc_kobject.h>
#include <kern/ipc_tt.h>
#include <kern/mach_param.h>
#include <kern/misc_protos.h>
#include <kern/kalloc.h>
#include <kern/zalloc.h>
#include <kern/queue.h>
#include <kern/task.h>

#include <sys/kdebug.h>

#include <mach/mach_voucher_attr_control.h>
#include <mach/machine/sdt.h>

extern int      proc_pid(void *);
extern int      proc_selfpid(void);
extern uint64_t proc_uniqueid(void *p);
extern char     *proc_name_address(void *p);

/*
 * Globals for delayed boost drop processing.
 */
static queue_head_t ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue;
static thread_call_t ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call;
static uint64_t ipc_importance_delayed_drop_timestamp;
static boolean_t ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call_requested = FALSE;

#define DENAP_DROP_TARGET (1000 * NSEC_PER_MSEC) /* optimum denap delay */
#define DENAP_DROP_SKEW    (100 * NSEC_PER_MSEC) /* request skew for wakeup */
#define DENAP_DROP_LEEWAY  (2 * DENAP_DROP_SKEW)  /* specified wakeup leeway */

#define DENAP_DROP_DELAY (DENAP_DROP_TARGET + DENAP_DROP_SKEW)
#define DENAP_DROP_FLAGS (THREAD_CALL_DELAY_SYS_NORMAL | THREAD_CALL_DELAY_LEEWAY)

/*
 * Importance Voucher Attribute Manager
 */

static lck_spin_t ipc_importance_lock_data;     /* single lock for now */


#define ipc_importance_lock_init() \
        lck_spin_init(&ipc_importance_lock_data, &ipc_lck_grp, &ipc_lck_attr)
#define ipc_importance_lock_destroy() \
        lck_spin_destroy(&ipc_importance_lock_data, &ipc_lck_grp)
#define ipc_importance_lock() \
        lck_spin_lock(&ipc_importance_lock_data)
#define ipc_importance_lock_try() \
        lck_spin_try_lock(&ipc_importance_lock_data)
#define ipc_importance_unlock() \
        lck_spin_unlock(&ipc_importance_lock_data)
#define ipc_importance_sleep(elem) lck_spin_sleep(&ipc_importance_lock_data,    \
                                        LCK_SLEEP_DEFAULT,                      \
                                        (event_t)(elem),                        \
                                        THREAD_UNINT)
#define ipc_importance_wakeup(elem) thread_wakeup((event_t)(elem))

#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
#define incr_ref_counter(x) (hw_atomic_add(&(x), 1))

static inline
uint32_t ipc_importance_reference_internal(ipc_importance_elem_t elem) 
{
        incr_ref_counter(elem->iie_refs_added);
        return (hw_atomic_add(&elem->iie_bits, 1) & IIE_REFS_MASK);
}

static inline
uint32_t ipc_importance_release_internal(ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
        incr_ref_counter(elem->iie_refs_dropped);
        return (hw_atomic_sub(&elem->iie_bits, 1) & IIE_REFS_MASK);
}

static inline 
uint32_t ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
  uint32_t out;
  out = ipc_importance_reference_internal(&task_imp->iit_elem);
  incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_added);
  return out;
}

static inline
uint32_t ipc_importance_task_release_internal(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
  uint32_t out;

  assert(1 < IIT_REFS(task_imp));
  incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_dropped);
  out = ipc_importance_release_internal(&task_imp->iit_elem);
  return out;
}

static inline
void ipc_importance_counter_init(ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
  
        elem->iie_refs_added = 0;
        elem->iie_refs_dropped = 0;
        elem->iie_kmsg_refs_added = 0;
        elem->iie_kmsg_refs_inherited = 0;
        elem->iie_kmsg_refs_coalesced = 0;
        elem->iie_kmsg_refs_dropped = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_added = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_added_inherit_from = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_added_transition = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_self_added = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_inherited = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_coalesced = 0;
        elem->iie_task_refs_dropped = 0;
}
#else
#define incr_ref_counter(x)
#endif

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
static queue_head_t global_iit_alloc_queue;
#endif

/* TODO: remove this varibale when interactive daemon audit is complete */
boolean_t ipc_importance_interactive_receiver = FALSE;

static zone_t ipc_importance_task_zone;
static zone_t ipc_importance_inherit_zone;

static ipc_voucher_attr_control_t ipc_importance_control;

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_kmsg_link
 *      Purpose:
 *              Link the kmsg onto the appropriate propagation chain.
 *              If the element is a task importance, we link directly
 *              on its propagation chain. Otherwise, we link onto the
 *              destination task of the inherit.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Importance lock held.
 *              Caller is donating an importance elem reference to the kmsg.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_kmsg_link(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg,
        ipc_importance_elem_t   elem)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t link_elem;

        assert(IIE_NULL == kmsg->ikm_importance);

        link_elem = (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) ?
                (ipc_importance_elem_t)((ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem)->iii_to_task :
                elem;

        queue_enter(&link_elem->iie_kmsgs, kmsg, ipc_kmsg_t, ikm_inheritance);
        kmsg->ikm_importance = elem;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink
 *      Purpose:
 *              Unlink the kmsg from its current propagation chain.
 *              If the element is a task importance, we unlink directly
 *              from its propagation chain. Otherwise, we unlink from the
 *              destination task of the inherit.
 *      Returns:
 *              The reference to the importance element it was linked on.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Importance lock held.
 *              Caller is responsible for dropping reference on returned elem.
 */
static ipc_importance_elem_t
ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem = kmsg->ikm_importance;

        if (IIE_NULL != elem) {
                ipc_importance_elem_t unlink_elem;

                unlink_elem = (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) ?
                        (ipc_importance_elem_t)((ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem)->iii_to_task : 
                        elem;

                queue_remove(&unlink_elem->iie_kmsgs, kmsg, ipc_kmsg_t, ikm_inheritance);
                kmsg->ikm_importance = IIE_NULL;
        }
        return elem;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_link
 *      Purpose:
 *              Link the inherit onto the appropriate propagation chain.
 *              If the element is a task importance, we link directly
 *              on its propagation chain. Otherwise, we link onto the
 *              destination task of the inherit.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Importance lock held.
 *              Caller is donating an elem importance reference to the inherit.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_inherit_link(
        ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit,
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t link_elem;

        assert(IIE_NULL == inherit->iii_from_elem);
        link_elem = (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) ?
                (ipc_importance_elem_t)((ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem)->iii_to_task :
                elem;

        queue_enter(&link_elem->iie_inherits, inherit, 
                    ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance);
        inherit->iii_from_elem = elem;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_unlink
 *      Purpose:
 *              Unlink the inherit from its current propagation chain.
 *              If the element is a task importance, we unlink directly
 *              from its propagation chain. Otherwise, we unlink from the
 *              destination task of the inherit.
 *      Returns:
 *              The reference to the importance element it was linked on.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Importance lock held.
 *              Caller is responsible for dropping reference on returned elem.
 */
static ipc_importance_elem_t
ipc_importance_inherit_unlink(
        ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem = inherit->iii_from_elem;

        if (IIE_NULL != elem) {
                ipc_importance_elem_t unlink_elem;

                unlink_elem = (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) ?
                        (ipc_importance_elem_t)((ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem)->iii_to_task : 
                        elem;

                queue_remove(&unlink_elem->iie_inherits, inherit, 
                             ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance);
                inherit->iii_from_elem = IIE_NULL;
        }
        return elem;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_reference
 *      Purpose:
 *              Add a reference to the importance element.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Caller must hold a reference on the element.
 */
void
ipc_importance_reference(ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
        assert(0 < IIE_REFS(elem));
        ipc_importance_reference_internal(elem);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_release_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on an importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Entered with importance lock held, leaves with it unlocked.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_release_locked(ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
        assert(0 < IIE_REFS(elem));

        if (0 < ipc_importance_release_internal(elem)) {

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
                ipc_importance_inherit_t temp_inherit;
                ipc_importance_task_t link_task;
                ipc_kmsg_t temp_kmsg;
                uint32_t expected = 0;

                if (0 < elem->iie_made)
                        expected++;

                link_task = (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) ?
                        ((ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem)->iii_to_task : 
                        (ipc_importance_task_t)elem;

                queue_iterate(&link_task->iit_kmsgs, temp_kmsg, ipc_kmsg_t, ikm_inheritance)
                        if (temp_kmsg->ikm_importance == elem)
                                expected++;
                queue_iterate(&link_task->iit_inherits, temp_inherit,
                              ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance)
                        if (temp_inherit->iii_from_elem == elem)
                                expected++;

                if (IIE_REFS(elem) < expected)
                        panic("ipc_importance_release_locked (%p)", elem);
#endif
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return;
        }

        /* last ref */
        /* can't get to no refs if we contribute to something else's importance */
        assert(queue_empty(&elem->iie_kmsgs));
        assert(queue_empty(&elem->iie_inherits));

        switch (IIE_TYPE(elem)) {

        /* just a "from" task reference to drop */
        case IIE_TYPE_TASK:
        {
                ipc_importance_task_t task_elem;

                task_elem = (ipc_importance_task_t)elem;
                assert(TASK_NULL == task_elem->iit_task);

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
                queue_remove(&global_iit_alloc_queue, task_elem, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_allocation);
#endif

                ipc_importance_unlock();

                zfree(ipc_importance_task_zone, task_elem);
                break;
        }

        /* dropping an inherit element */
        case IIE_TYPE_INHERIT:
        {
                ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit;
                ipc_importance_elem_t from_elem;
                ipc_importance_task_t to_task;


                inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem;
                to_task = inherit->iii_to_task;
                assert(IIT_NULL != to_task);
                assert(!inherit->iii_donating);

                /* unlink and release the inherit */
                assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(to_task));
                from_elem = ipc_importance_inherit_unlink(inherit);
                assert(IIE_NULL != from_elem);
                ipc_importance_release_locked(from_elem);
                /* unlocked on return */

                ipc_importance_task_release(to_task);

                zfree(ipc_importance_inherit_zone, inherit);
                break;
        }
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_release
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on an importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              May block.
 */
void
ipc_importance_release(ipc_importance_elem_t elem)
{
        if (IIE_NULL == elem)
                return;

        ipc_importance_lock();
        ipc_importance_release_locked(elem);
        /* unlocked */
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_reference


 *      Purpose:
 *              Retain a reference on a task importance attribute value.
 *      Conditions:
 *              nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              caller holds a reference already.
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_reference(ipc_importance_task_t task_elem)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_elem)
                return;
#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
        incr_ref_counter(task_elem->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_added);
#endif
        ipc_importance_reference(&task_elem->iit_elem);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_release
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on a task importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              May block.
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_release(ipc_importance_task_t task_elem)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_elem)
                return;

        ipc_importance_lock();
#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
        incr_ref_counter(task_elem->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_dropped);
#endif
        ipc_importance_release_locked(&task_elem->iit_elem);
        /* unlocked */
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_release_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on a task importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              importance lock held on entry, nothing locked on exit.
 *              May block.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_release_locked(ipc_importance_task_t task_elem)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_elem) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return;
        }
#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
        incr_ref_counter(task_elem->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_dropped);
#endif
        ipc_importance_release_locked(&task_elem->iit_elem);
        /* unlocked */
}

/*
 * Routines for importance donation/inheritance/boosting
 */


/*
 * External importance assertions are managed by the process in userspace
 * Internal importance assertions are the responsibility of the kernel
 * Assertions are changed from internal to external via task_importance_externalize_assertion
 */

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_check_transition
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increase or decrement the internal task importance counter of the
 *              specified task and determine if propagation and a task policy
 *              update is required.
 *
 *              If it is already enqueued for a policy update, steal it from that queue
 *              (as we are reversing that update before it happens).
 *
 *      Conditions:
 *              Called with the importance lock held.
 *              It is the caller's responsibility to perform the propagation of the
 *              transition and/or policy changes by checking the return value.
 */
static boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_check_transition(
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp,
        iit_update_type_t type,
        uint32_t delta)
{

        task_t target_task = task_imp->iit_task;
        boolean_t boost = (IIT_UPDATE_HOLD == type);
        boolean_t before_boosted, after_boosted;

        if (!ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp))
                return FALSE;

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        int target_pid = (TASK_NULL != target_task) ? audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task) : -1;

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (((boost) ? IMP_HOLD : IMP_DROP) | TASK_POLICY_INTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                                          proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        /* snapshot the effective boosting status before making any changes */
        before_boosted = (task_imp->iit_assertcnt > 0);

        /* Adjust the assertcnt appropriately */
        if (boost) {
                task_imp->iit_assertcnt += delta;
#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        DTRACE_BOOST6(send_boost, task_t, target_task, int, target_pid,
                      task_t, current_task(), int, proc_selfpid(), int, delta, int, task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
#endif
        } else {
                // assert(delta <= task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
                if (delta > task_imp->iit_assertcnt - IIT_EXTERN(task_imp)) {
                        /* TODO: Turn this back into a panic <rdar://problem/12592649> */
                        if (target_task != TASK_NULL) {
                                printf("Over-release of kernel-internal importance assertions for pid %d (%s), "
                                       "dropping %d assertion(s) but task only has %d remaining (%d external).\n",
                                       audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task),
                                       (target_task->bsd_info == NULL) ? "" : proc_name_address(target_task->bsd_info),
                                       delta,
                                       task_imp->iit_assertcnt,
                                       IIT_EXTERN(task_imp));
                        }
                        task_imp->iit_assertcnt = IIT_EXTERN(task_imp);
                } else {
                        task_imp->iit_assertcnt -= delta;
                }
#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
                // This convers both legacy and voucher-based importance.
                DTRACE_BOOST4(drop_boost, task_t, target_task, int, target_pid, int, delta, int, task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
#endif
        }

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (((boost) ? IMP_HOLD : IMP_DROP) | TASK_POLICY_INTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_END,
                                  proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        /* did the change result in an effective donor status change? */
        after_boosted = (task_imp->iit_assertcnt > 0);

        if (after_boosted != before_boosted) {

                /* 
                 * If the task importance is already on an update queue, we just reversed the need for a
                 * pending policy update.  If the queue is any other than the delayed-drop-queue, pull it 
                 * off that queue and release the reference it got going onto the update queue.  If it is
                 * the delayed-drop-queue we leave it in place in case it comes back into the drop state
                 * before its time delay is up.
                 *
                 * We still need to propagate the change downstream to reverse the assertcnt effects,
                 * but we no longer need to update this task's boost policy state.
                 *
                 * Otherwise, mark it as needing a policy update.
                 */
                assert(0 == task_imp->iit_updatepolicy);
                if (NULL != task_imp->iit_updateq) {
                        if (&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue != task_imp->iit_updateq) {
                                queue_remove(task_imp->iit_updateq, task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                                task_imp->iit_updateq = NULL;
                                ipc_importance_task_release_internal(task_imp); /* can't be last ref */
                        }
                } else {
                        task_imp->iit_updatepolicy = 1;
                }
                return TRUE;
        }

        return FALSE;
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_propagate_helper
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increase or decrement the internal task importance counter of all
 *              importance tasks inheriting from the specified one.  If this causes
 *              that importance task to change state, add it to the list of tasks
 *              to do a policy update against.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Called with the importance lock held.
 *              It is the caller's responsibility to iterate down the generated list
 *              and propagate any subsequent assertion changes from there.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_propagate_helper(
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp,
        iit_update_type_t type,
        queue_t propagation)
{
        ipc_importance_task_t temp_task_imp;

        /* 
         * iterate the downstream kmsgs, adjust their boosts, 
         * and capture the next task to adjust for each message
         */

        ipc_kmsg_t temp_kmsg;

        queue_iterate(&task_imp->iit_kmsgs, temp_kmsg, ipc_kmsg_t, ikm_inheritance) {
                mach_msg_header_t *hdr = temp_kmsg->ikm_header;
                mach_port_delta_t delta;
                ipc_port_t port;

                /* toggle the kmsg importance bit as a barrier to parallel adjusts */
                if (IIT_UPDATE_HOLD == type) {
                        if (MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(hdr->msgh_bits)) {
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* mark the message as now carrying importance */
                        hdr->msgh_bits |= MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                        delta = 1;
                } else {
                        if (!MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(hdr->msgh_bits)) {
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* clear the message as now carrying importance */
                        hdr->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                        delta = -1;
                }

                /* determine the task importance to adjust as result (if any) */
                port = (ipc_port_t) hdr->msgh_remote_port;
                assert(IP_VALID(port));
                ip_lock(port);
                temp_task_imp = IIT_NULL;
                if (!ipc_port_importance_delta_internal(port, &delta, &temp_task_imp)) {
                        ip_unlock(port);
                }

                /* no task importance to adjust associated with the port? */
                if (IIT_NULL == temp_task_imp) {
                        continue;
                }

                /* hold a reference on temp_task_imp */

                /* Adjust the task assertions and determine if an edge was crossed */
                if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(temp_task_imp, type, 1)) {
                        incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_added_transition);
                        queue_enter(propagation, temp_task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_props);
                        /* reference donated */
                } else {
                        ipc_importance_task_release_internal(temp_task_imp);
                }
        }

        /*
         * iterate the downstream importance inherits
         * and capture the next task importance to boost for each
         */
        ipc_importance_inherit_t temp_inherit;

        queue_iterate(&task_imp->iit_inherits, temp_inherit, ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance) {
                uint32_t assertcnt = III_EXTERN(temp_inherit); 

                temp_task_imp = temp_inherit->iii_to_task;
                assert(IIT_NULL != temp_task_imp);

                if (IIT_UPDATE_HOLD == type) {
                        /* if no undropped externcnts in the inherit, nothing to do */
                        if (0 == assertcnt) {
                                assert(temp_inherit->iii_donating == FALSE);
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* nothing to do if the inherit is already donating (forced donation) */
                        if (temp_inherit->iii_donating) {
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* mark it donating and contribute to the task externcnts */
                        temp_inherit->iii_donating = TRUE;
                        temp_task_imp->iit_externcnt += temp_inherit->iii_externcnt;
                        temp_task_imp->iit_externdrop += temp_inherit->iii_externdrop;

                } else {
                        /* if no contributing assertions, move on */
                        if (0 == assertcnt) {
                                assert(temp_inherit->iii_donating == FALSE);
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* nothing to do if the inherit is not donating */
                        if (!temp_inherit->iii_donating) { 
                                continue;
                        }

                        /* mark it no longer donating */
                        temp_inherit->iii_donating = FALSE;

                        /* remove the contribution the inherit made to the to-task */
                        assert(IIT_EXTERN(temp_task_imp) >= III_EXTERN(temp_inherit));
                        assert(temp_task_imp->iit_externcnt >= temp_inherit->iii_externcnt);
                        assert(temp_task_imp->iit_externdrop >= temp_inherit->iii_externdrop);
                        temp_task_imp->iit_externcnt -= temp_inherit->iii_externcnt;
                        temp_task_imp->iit_externdrop -= temp_inherit->iii_externdrop;

                }

                /* Adjust the task assertions and determine if an edge was crossed */
                assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(temp_task_imp));
                if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(temp_task_imp, type, assertcnt)) {
                        ipc_importance_task_reference(temp_task_imp);
                        incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_added_transition);
                        queue_enter(propagation, temp_task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_props);
                } 
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_process_updates
 *      Purpose:
 *              Process the queue of task importances and apply the policy
 *              update called for.  Only process tasks in the queue with an
 *              update timestamp less than the supplied max.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Called and returns with importance locked.
 *              May drop importance lock and block temporarily.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_process_updates(
        queue_t   supplied_queue,
        boolean_t boost,
        uint64_t  max_timestamp)
{
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;
        queue_head_t second_chance;
        queue_t queue = supplied_queue;

        /*
         * This queue will hold the task's we couldn't trylock on first pass.
         * By using a second (private) queue, we guarantee all tasks that get
         * entered on this queue have a timestamp under the maximum.
         */
        queue_init(&second_chance);

        /* process any resulting policy updates */
 retry:
        while(!queue_empty(queue)) {
                task_t target_task;
                struct task_pend_token pend_token = {};

                task_imp = (ipc_importance_task_t)queue_first(queue);
                assert(0 == task_imp->iit_updatepolicy);
                assert(queue == task_imp->iit_updateq);

                /* if timestamp is too big, we're done */
                if (task_imp->iit_updatetime > max_timestamp) {
                        break;
                }

                /* we were given a reference on each task in the queue */

                /* remove it from the supplied queue */
                queue_remove(queue, task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                task_imp->iit_updateq = NULL;

                target_task = task_imp->iit_task;

                /* Is it well on the way to exiting? */
                if (TASK_NULL == target_task) {
                        ipc_importance_task_release_locked(task_imp);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        continue;
                }

                /* Has the update been reversed on the hysteresis queue? */
                if (0 < task_imp->iit_assertcnt &&
                    queue == &ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue) {
                        ipc_importance_task_release_locked(task_imp);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        continue;
                }

                /* 
                 * Can we get the task lock out-of-order? 
                 * If not, stick this back on the second-chance queue.
                 */
                if (!task_lock_try(target_task)) {
                        boolean_t should_wait_lock = (queue == &second_chance);
                        task_imp->iit_updateq = &second_chance;
                
                        /*
                         * If we're already processing second-chances on
                         * tasks, keep this task on the front of the queue.
                         * We will wait for the task lock before coming
                         * back and trying again, and we have a better
                         * chance of re-acquiring the lock if we come back
                         * to it right away.
                         */
                        if (should_wait_lock){
                                task_reference(target_task);
                                queue_enter_first(&second_chance, task_imp,
                                                  ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                        } else {
                                queue_enter(&second_chance, task_imp, 
                                            ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                        }
                        ipc_importance_unlock();
                        
                        if (should_wait_lock) {
                                task_lock(target_task);
                                task_unlock(target_task);
                                task_deallocate(target_task);
                        }

                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        continue;
                }

                /* is it going away? */
                if (!target_task->active) {
                        task_unlock(target_task);
                        ipc_importance_task_release_locked(task_imp);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        continue;
                }

                /* take a task reference for while we don't have the importance lock */
                task_reference(target_task);

                /* count the transition */
                if (boost)
                        task_imp->iit_transitions++;

                ipc_importance_unlock();

                /* apply the policy adjust to the target task (while it is still locked) */
                task_update_boost_locked(target_task, boost, &pend_token);

                /* complete the policy update with the task unlocked */
                ipc_importance_task_release(task_imp);
                task_unlock(target_task);
                task_policy_update_complete_unlocked(target_task, THREAD_NULL, &pend_token);
                task_deallocate(target_task);

                ipc_importance_lock();
        }

        /* If there are tasks we couldn't update the first time, try again */
        if (!queue_empty(&second_chance)) {
                queue = &second_chance;
                goto retry;
        }
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop_scan
 *      Purpose:
 *              The thread call routine to scan the delayed drop queue,
 *              requesting all updates with a deadline up to the last target
 *              for the thread-call (which is DENAP_DROP_SKEW beyond the first
 *              thread's optimum delay).
 *              update to drop its boost.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop_scan(
        __unused void *arg1,
        __unused void *arg2) 
{
        ipc_importance_lock();

        /* process all queued task drops with timestamps up to TARGET(first)+SKEW */
        ipc_importance_task_process_updates(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue, 
                                            FALSE,
                                            ipc_importance_delayed_drop_timestamp);

        /* importance lock may have been temporarily dropped */

        /* If there are any entries left in the queue, re-arm the call here */
        if (!queue_empty(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue)) {
                ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;
                uint64_t deadline;
                uint64_t leeway;

                task_imp = (ipc_importance_task_t)queue_first(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue);

                nanoseconds_to_absolutetime(DENAP_DROP_DELAY, &deadline);
                deadline += task_imp->iit_updatetime;
                ipc_importance_delayed_drop_timestamp = deadline;

                nanoseconds_to_absolutetime(DENAP_DROP_LEEWAY, &leeway);

                thread_call_enter_delayed_with_leeway(
                                        ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call,
                                        NULL,
                                        deadline,
                                        leeway,
                                        DENAP_DROP_FLAGS);
        } else {
                ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call_requested = FALSE;
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop
 *      Purpose:
 *              Queue the specified task importance for delayed policy
 *              update to drop its boost.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Called with the importance lock held.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        uint64_t timestamp = mach_absolute_time(); /* no mach_approximate_time() in kernel */

        assert(ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call != NULL);

        /*
         * If still on an update queue from a previous change,
         * remove it first (and use that reference).  Otherwise, take
         * a new reference for the delay drop update queue.
         */
        if (NULL != task_imp->iit_updateq) {
                queue_remove(task_imp->iit_updateq, task_imp, 
                             ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
        } else {
                ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(task_imp);
        }

        task_imp->iit_updateq = &ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue;
        task_imp->iit_updatetime = timestamp;

        queue_enter(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue, task_imp, 
                    ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);

        /* request the delayed thread-call if not already requested */
        if (!ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call_requested) {
                uint64_t deadline;
                uint64_t leeway;

                nanoseconds_to_absolutetime(DENAP_DROP_DELAY, &deadline);
                deadline += task_imp->iit_updatetime;
                ipc_importance_delayed_drop_timestamp = deadline;

                nanoseconds_to_absolutetime(DENAP_DROP_LEEWAY, &leeway);

                ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call_requested = TRUE;
                thread_call_enter_delayed_with_leeway(
                                        ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call,
                                        NULL,
                                        deadline,
                                        leeway,
                                        DENAP_DROP_FLAGS);
        }
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Propagate the importance transition type to every item
 *              If this causes a boost to be applied, determine if that
 *              boost should propagate downstream.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Called with the importance lock held.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp,
        iit_update_type_t type,
        boolean_t update_task_imp)
{
        boolean_t boost = (IIT_UPDATE_HOLD == type);
        ipc_importance_task_t temp_task_imp;
        queue_head_t propagate;
        queue_head_t updates;

        queue_init(&updates);
        queue_init(&propagate);

        /*
         * If we're going to update the policy for the provided task,
         * enqueue it on the propagate queue itself.  Otherwise, only
         * enqueue downstream things.
         */
        if (update_task_imp) {
                queue_enter(&propagate, task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_props);
        } else {
                ipc_importance_task_propagate_helper(task_imp, type, &propagate);
        }

        /*
         * for each item on the propagation list, propagate any change downstream,
         * adding new tasks to propagate further if they transistioned as well.
         */
        while (!queue_empty(&propagate)) {
                boolean_t need_update;

                queue_remove_first(&propagate, temp_task_imp, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_props);
                assert(IIT_NULL != temp_task_imp);

                /* only propagate for receivers not already marked as a donor */
                if (!ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(temp_task_imp) &&
                    ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(temp_task_imp)) {
                        ipc_importance_task_propagate_helper(temp_task_imp, type, &propagate);
                }

                /* if we have a policy update to apply, enqueue a reference for later processing */
                need_update = (0 != temp_task_imp->iit_updatepolicy);
                temp_task_imp->iit_updatepolicy = 0;
                if (need_update && TASK_NULL != temp_task_imp->iit_task) {
                        if (NULL == temp_task_imp->iit_updateq) {
                                temp_task_imp->iit_updatetime = 0;
                                temp_task_imp->iit_updateq = &updates;
                                ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(temp_task_imp);
                                if (boost) {
                                        queue_enter(&updates, temp_task_imp,
                                                    ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                                } else {
                                        queue_enter_first(&updates, temp_task_imp,
                                                          ipc_importance_task_t, iit_updates);
                                }
                        } else {
                                /* Must already be on the AppNap hysteresis queue */
                                assert(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue);
                                assert(ipc_importance_task_is_marked_denap_receiver(temp_task_imp));
                        }       
                }
        }

        /* apply updates to task (may drop importance lock) */
        if (!queue_empty(&updates)) {
                ipc_importance_task_process_updates(&updates, boost, 0);
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increment the assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a boost state change in that task,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND, if
 *              if not just waking out of App Nap, all down-stream
 *              tasks that have a similar transition through inheriting
 *              this update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              importance locked on entry and exit.
 *              May temporarily drop importance lock and block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion_locked(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_HOLD, count)) {
                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_HOLD, TRUE);
        }
        return KERN_SUCCESS;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Decrement the assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a boost state change in that task,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND, if
 *              if not just waking out of App Nap, all down-stream
 *              tasks that have a similar transition through inheriting
 *              this update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              importance locked on entry and exit.
 *              May temporarily drop importance lock and block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion_locked(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, count)) {
                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, TRUE);
        }
        return KERN_SUCCESS;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increment the assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a 0->1 change in that count,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND
 *              (potentially) all down-stream tasks that have a
 *              similar transition through inheriting this update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked
 *              May block after dropping importance lock.
 */
int
ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        int ret = KERN_SUCCESS;

        if (ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp)) {
                ipc_importance_lock();
                ret = ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion_locked(task_imp, count);
                ipc_importance_unlock();
        }
        return ret;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Decrement the assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a X->0 change in that count,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND
 *              all down-stream tasks that have a similar transition
 *              through inheriting this drop update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.
 *              May block after dropping importance lock.
 */
kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        kern_return_t ret = KERN_SUCCESS;

        if (ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp)) {
                ipc_importance_lock();
                ret = ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion_locked(task_imp, count);
                ipc_importance_unlock();
        }
        return ret;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_hold_file_lock_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increment the file lock assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a 0->1 change in that count,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND
 *              (potentially) all down-stream tasks that have a
 *              similar transition through inheriting this update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked
 *              May block after dropping importance lock.
 */
kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_hold_file_lock_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        kern_return_t ret = KERN_SUCCESS;

        if (ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp)) {
                ipc_importance_lock();
                ret = ipc_importance_task_hold_internal_assertion_locked(task_imp, count);
                if (KERN_SUCCESS == ret) {
                        task_imp->iit_filelocks += count;
                }
                ipc_importance_unlock();
        }
        return ret;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_drop_file_lock_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Decrement the assertion count on the task importance.
 *              If this results in a X->0 change in that count,
 *              prepare to update task policy for this task AND
 *              all down-stream tasks that have a similar transition
 *              through inheriting this drop update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.
 *              May block after dropping importance lock.
 */
kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_drop_file_lock_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        kern_return_t ret = KERN_SUCCESS;

        if (ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp)) {
                ipc_importance_lock();
                if (count <= task_imp->iit_filelocks) {
                        task_imp->iit_filelocks -= count;
                        ret = ipc_importance_task_drop_internal_assertion_locked(task_imp, count);
                } else {
                        ret = KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;
                }
                ipc_importance_unlock();
        }
        return ret;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_hold_legacy_external_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Increment the external assertion count on the task importance.
 *              This cannot result in an 0->1 transition, as the caller must
 *              already hold an external boost.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.
 *              May block after dropping importance lock.
 *              A queue of task importance structures is returned
 *              by ipc_importance_task_hold_assertion_locked(). Each
 *              needs to be updated (outside the importance lock hold).
 */
kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_hold_legacy_external_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        task_t target_task;
        uint32_t target_assertcnt;
        uint32_t target_externcnt;
        uint32_t target_legacycnt;

        kern_return_t ret;

        ipc_importance_lock();
        target_task = task_imp->iit_task;

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        int target_pid = (TASK_NULL != target_task) ? audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task) : -1;

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (IMP_HOLD | TASK_POLICY_EXTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        if (IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) == 0) {
                /* Only allowed to take a new boost assertion when holding an external boost */
                /* save data for diagnostic printf below */
                target_assertcnt = task_imp->iit_assertcnt;
                target_externcnt = IIT_EXTERN(task_imp);
                target_legacycnt = IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp);
                ret = KERN_FAILURE;
                count = 0;
        } else {
                assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp));
                assert(0 < task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
                assert(0 < IIT_EXTERN(task_imp));
                task_imp->iit_assertcnt += count;
                task_imp->iit_externcnt += count;
                task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt += count;
                ret = KERN_SUCCESS;
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (IMP_HOLD | TASK_POLICY_EXTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_END,
                                  proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
        // This covers the legacy case where a task takes an extra boost.
        DTRACE_BOOST5(receive_boost, task_t, target_task, int, target_pid, int, proc_selfpid(), int, count, int, task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
#endif

        if (KERN_FAILURE == ret && target_task != TASK_NULL) {
                printf("BUG in process %s[%d]: "
                       "attempt to acquire an additional legacy external boost assertion without holding an existing legacy external assertion. "
                       "(%d total, %d external, %d legacy-external)\n",
                       proc_name_address(target_task->bsd_info), audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task),
                       target_assertcnt, target_externcnt, target_legacycnt);
        }

        return(ret);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_drop_legacy_external_assertion
 *      Purpose:
 *              Drop the legacy external assertion count on the task and
 *              reflect that change to total external assertion count and
 *              then onto the internal importance count.
 *
 *              If this results in a X->0 change in the internal,
 *              count, prepare to update task policy for this task AND
 *              all down-stream tasks that have a similar transition
 *              through inheriting this update.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.
 */
kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_drop_legacy_external_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count)
{
        int ret = KERN_SUCCESS;
        task_t target_task;
        uint32_t target_assertcnt;
        uint32_t target_externcnt;
        uint32_t target_legacycnt;

        if (count > 1) {
                return KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;
        }
                
        ipc_importance_lock();
        target_task = task_imp->iit_task;

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        int target_pid = (TASK_NULL != target_task) ? audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task) : -1;

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (IMP_DROP | TASK_POLICY_EXTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        if (count > IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp)) {
                /* Process over-released its boost count - save data for diagnostic printf */
                /* TODO: If count > 1, we should clear out as many external assertions as there are left. */
                target_assertcnt = task_imp->iit_assertcnt;
                target_externcnt = IIT_EXTERN(task_imp);
                target_legacycnt = IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp);
                ret = KERN_FAILURE;
        } else {
                /* 
                 * decrement legacy external count from the top level and reflect
                 * into internal for this and all subsequent updates.
                 */
                assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp));
                assert(IIT_EXTERN(task_imp) >= count);

                task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop += count;
                task_imp->iit_externdrop += count;

                /* reset extern counters (if appropriate) */
                if (IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) == 0) {
                        if (IIT_EXTERN(task_imp) != 0) {
                                task_imp->iit_externcnt -= task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt;
                                task_imp->iit_externdrop -= task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop;
                        } else {
                                task_imp->iit_externcnt = 0;
                                task_imp->iit_externdrop = 0;
                        }
                        task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt = 0;
                        task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop = 0;
                }
                
                /* reflect the drop to the internal assertion count (and effect any importance change) */
                if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, count)) {
                        ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, TRUE);
                }
                ret = KERN_SUCCESS;
        }

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
                KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, (IMP_DROP | TASK_POLICY_EXTERNAL))) | DBG_FUNC_END,
                                          proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        ipc_importance_unlock();

        /* delayed printf for user-supplied data failures */
        if (KERN_FAILURE == ret && TASK_NULL != target_task) {
                printf("BUG in process %s[%d]: over-released legacy external boost assertions (%d total, %d external, %d legacy-external)\n",
                       proc_name_address(target_task->bsd_info), audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task),
                       target_assertcnt, target_externcnt, target_legacycnt);
        }

        return(ret);
}



/* Transfer an assertion to legacy userspace responsibility */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_task_externalize_legacy_assertion(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, uint32_t count, __unused int sender_pid)
{
        task_t target_task;

        assert(IIT_NULL != task_imp);
        target_task = task_imp->iit_task;

        if (TASK_NULL == target_task ||
            !ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_imp)) {
                return KERN_FAILURE;
        }

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        int target_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task);

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, IMP_EXTERN)) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
#endif

        ipc_importance_lock();
        /* assert(task_imp->iit_assertcnt >= IIT_EXTERN(task_imp) + count); */
        assert(IIT_EXTERN(task_imp) >= IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp));
        task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt += count;
        task_imp->iit_externcnt += count;
        ipc_importance_unlock();

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_ASSERTION, IMP_EXTERN)) | DBG_FUNC_END,
                                  proc_selfpid(), target_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp), 0);
    // This is the legacy boosting path
        DTRACE_BOOST5(receive_boost, task_t, target_task, int, target_pid, int, sender_pid, int, count, int, IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp));
#endif /* IMPORTANCE_DEBUG */

        return(KERN_SUCCESS);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_update_live_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Read the live donor status and update the live_donor bit/propagate the change in importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *
 *              TODO: Need tracepoints around this function...
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_update_live_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        uint32_t task_live_donor;
        boolean_t before_donor;
        boolean_t after_donor;
        task_t target_task;
  
        assert(task_imp != NULL);

        /*
         * Nothing to do if the task is not marked as expecting
         * live donor updates.
         */
        if (!ipc_importance_task_is_marked_live_donor(task_imp)) {
                return;
        }

        ipc_importance_lock();

        /* If the task got disconnected on the way here, no use (or ability) adjusting live donor status */
        target_task = task_imp->iit_task;
        if (TASK_NULL == target_task) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return;
        }
        before_donor = ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(task_imp);

        /* snapshot task live donor status - may change, but another call will accompany the change */
        task_live_donor = target_task->effective_policy.t_live_donor;

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        int target_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(target_task);

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE,
                                  (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_DONOR_CHANGE, IMP_DONOR_UPDATE_LIVE_DONOR_STATE)) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                                  target_pid, task_imp->iit_donor, task_live_donor, before_donor, 0);
#endif                            

        /* update the task importance live donor status based on the task's value */
        task_imp->iit_donor = task_live_donor;

        after_donor = ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(task_imp);

        /* Has the effectiveness of being a donor changed as a result of this update? */
        if (before_donor != after_donor) {
                iit_update_type_t type;

                /* propagate assertions without updating the current task policy (already handled) */
                if (0 == before_donor) {
                        task_imp->iit_transitions++;
                        type = IIT_UPDATE_HOLD;
                } else {
                        type = IIT_UPDATE_DROP;
                }
                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(task_imp, type, FALSE);
        }

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE,
                                  (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_DONOR_CHANGE, IMP_DONOR_UPDATE_LIVE_DONOR_STATE)) | DBG_FUNC_END,
                                  target_pid, task_imp->iit_donor, task_live_donor, after_donor, 0);
#endif

        ipc_importance_unlock();
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_mark_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Set the task importance donor flag.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *
 *              This is only called while the task is being constructed,
 *              so no need to update task policy or propagate downstream.
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_mark_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t donating)
{
        assert(task_imp != NULL);

        ipc_importance_lock();

        int old_donor = task_imp->iit_donor;

        task_imp->iit_donor = (donating ? 1 : 0);

        if (task_imp->iit_donor > 0 && old_donor == 0)
                task_imp->iit_transitions++;

        KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE,
                                  (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_DONOR_CHANGE, IMP_DONOR_INIT_DONOR_STATE)) | DBG_FUNC_NONE,
                                  audit_token_pid_from_task(task_imp->iit_task), donating,
                                  old_donor, task_imp->iit_donor, 0);
        
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_marked_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the donor flag for the given task importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock.
 *              In that case, donor status can change so you must
 *              check only once for each donation event.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                return FALSE;
        }
        return (0 != task_imp->iit_donor);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_mark_live_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Indicate that the task is eligible for live donor updates.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *
 *              This is only called while the task is being constructed.
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_mark_live_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t live_donating)
{
        assert(task_imp != NULL);

        ipc_importance_lock();
        task_imp->iit_live_donor = (live_donating ? 1 : 0);
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_marked_live_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the live donor and donor flags for the given task importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock.
 *              In that case, donor status can change so you must
 *              check only once for each donation event.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_marked_live_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                return FALSE;
        }
        return (0 != task_imp->iit_live_donor);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_is_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the full donor status for the given task importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock.
 *              In that case, donor status can change so you must
 *              check only once for each donation event.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                return FALSE;
        }
        return (ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(task_imp) ||
                (ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(task_imp) &&
                 task_imp->iit_assertcnt > 0));
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_is_never_donor
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query if a given task can ever donate importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock.
 *              Condition is permanent for a give task.         
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_never_donor(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                return FALSE;
        }
        return (!ipc_importance_task_is_marked_donor(task_imp) &&
                !ipc_importance_task_is_marked_live_donor(task_imp) &&
                !ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(task_imp));
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_mark_receiver
 *      Purpose:
 *              Update the task importance receiver flag.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              This can only be invoked before the task is discoverable,
 *              so no worries about atomicity(?)
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_mark_receiver(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t receiving)
{
        assert(task_imp != NULL);       

        ipc_importance_lock();
        if (receiving) {
                assert(task_imp->iit_assertcnt == 0);
                assert(task_imp->iit_externcnt == 0);
                assert(task_imp->iit_externdrop == 0);
                assert(task_imp->iit_denap == 0);
                task_imp->iit_receiver = 1;  /* task can receive importance boost */
        } else if (task_imp->iit_receiver) {
                assert(task_imp->iit_denap == 0);
                if (task_imp->iit_assertcnt != 0 || IIT_EXTERN(task_imp) != 0) {
                        panic("disabling imp_receiver on task with pending importance boosts!");
                }
                task_imp->iit_receiver = 0;
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_marked_receiver
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the receiver flag for the given task importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock as
 *              the importance flag can never change after task init.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        return (IIT_NULL != task_imp && 0 != task_imp->iit_receiver);
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_mark_denap_receiver
 *      Purpose:
 *              Update the task importance de-nap receiver flag.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              This can only be invoked before the task is discoverable,
 *              so no worries about atomicity(?)
 */
void
ipc_importance_task_mark_denap_receiver(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t denap)
{
        assert(task_imp != NULL);       

        ipc_importance_lock();
        if (denap) {
                assert(task_imp->iit_assertcnt == 0);
                assert(task_imp->iit_externcnt == 0);
                assert(task_imp->iit_receiver == 0);
                task_imp->iit_denap = 1;  /* task can receive de-nap boost */
        } else if (task_imp->iit_denap) {
                assert(task_imp->iit_receiver == 0);
                if (0 < task_imp->iit_assertcnt || 0 < IIT_EXTERN(task_imp)) {
                        panic("disabling de-nap on task with pending de-nap boosts!");
                }
                task_imp->iit_denap = 0;
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_marked_denap_receiver
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the de-nap receiver flag for the given task importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock as
 *              the de-nap flag can never change after task init.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_marked_denap_receiver(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        return (IIT_NULL != task_imp && 0 != task_imp->iit_denap);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_is_denap_receiver
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query the full de-nap receiver status for the given task importance.
 *              For now, that is simply whether the receiver flag is set.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock as
 *              the de-nap receiver flag can never change after task init.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_denap_receiver(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        return (ipc_importance_task_is_marked_denap_receiver(task_imp));
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type
 *      Purpose:
 *              Query if the task is marked to receive boosts - either
 *              importance or denap.
 *      Conditions:
 *              May be called without taking the importance lock as both
 *              the importance and de-nap receiver flags can never change
 *              after task init.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp)
{
        return (ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(task_imp) ||
                ipc_importance_task_is_marked_denap_receiver(task_imp));
}

#if 0 /* currently unused */

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_reference
 *      Purpose:
 *              Add a reference to the inherit importance element.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Caller most hold a reference on the inherit element.
 */
static inline void
ipc_importance_inherit_reference(ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit)
{
        ipc_importance_reference(&inherit->iii_elem);
}
#endif /* currently unused */

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_release_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on an inherit importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Entered with importance lock held, leaves with it unlocked.
 */
static inline void
ipc_importance_inherit_release_locked(ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit)
{
        ipc_importance_release_locked(&inherit->iii_elem);
}

#if 0 /* currently unused */
/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_release
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release a reference on an inherit importance attribute value,
 *              unlinking and deallocating the attribute if the last reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              nothing locked on entrance, nothing locked on exit.
 *              May block.
 */
void
ipc_importance_inherit_release(ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit)
{
        if (III_NULL != inherit)
                ipc_importance_release(&inherit->iii_elem);
}
#endif /* 0 currently unused */
        
/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_for_task
 *      Purpose:
 *              Create a reference for the specified task's base importance
 *              element.  If the base importance element doesn't exist, make it and
 *              bind it to the active task.  If the task is inactive, there isn't
 *              any need to return a new reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              If made is true, a "made" reference is returned (for donating to
 *              the voucher system).  Otherwise an internal reference is returned.
 *
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
ipc_importance_task_t
ipc_importance_for_task(task_t task, boolean_t made)
{
        ipc_importance_task_t task_elem;
        boolean_t first_pass = TRUE;

        assert(TASK_NULL != task);

 retry:
        /* No use returning anything for inactive task */
        if (!task->active)
                return IIT_NULL;

        ipc_importance_lock();
        task_elem = task->task_imp_base;
        if (IIT_NULL != task_elem) {
                /* Add a made reference (borrowing active task ref to do it) */
                if (made) {
                        if (0 == task_elem->iit_made++) {
                                assert(IIT_REFS_MAX > IIT_REFS(task_elem));
                                ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(task_elem);
                        }
                } else {
                        assert(IIT_REFS_MAX > IIT_REFS(task_elem));
                        ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(task_elem);
                }
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return task_elem;
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();

        if (!first_pass)
                return IIT_NULL;
        first_pass = FALSE;

        /* Need to make one - may race with others (be prepared to drop) */
        task_elem = (ipc_importance_task_t)zalloc(ipc_importance_task_zone);
        if (IIT_NULL == task_elem)
                goto retry;

        task_elem->iit_bits = IIE_TYPE_TASK | 2; /* one for task, one for return/made */
        task_elem->iit_made = (made) ? 1 : 0;
        task_elem->iit_task = task; /* take actual ref when we're sure */
        task_elem->iit_updateq = NULL;
        task_elem->iit_receiver = 0;
        task_elem->iit_denap = 0;
        task_elem->iit_donor = 0;
        task_elem->iit_live_donor = 0;
        task_elem->iit_updatepolicy = 0;
        task_elem->iit_reserved = 0;
        task_elem->iit_filelocks = 0;
        task_elem->iit_updatetime = 0;
        task_elem->iit_transitions = 0;
        task_elem->iit_assertcnt = 0;
        task_elem->iit_externcnt = 0;
        task_elem->iit_externdrop = 0;
        task_elem->iit_legacy_externcnt = 0;
        task_elem->iit_legacy_externdrop = 0;
#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
        ipc_importance_counter_init(&task_elem->iit_elem);
#endif
        queue_init(&task_elem->iit_kmsgs);
        queue_init(&task_elem->iit_inherits);

        ipc_importance_lock();
        if (!task->active) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                zfree(ipc_importance_task_zone, task_elem);
                return IIT_NULL;
        }

        /* did we lose the race? */
        if (IIT_NULL != task->task_imp_base) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                zfree(ipc_importance_task_zone, task_elem);
                goto retry;
        }

        /* we won the race */
        task->task_imp_base = task_elem;
        task_reference(task);
#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
        queue_enter(&global_iit_alloc_queue, task_elem, ipc_importance_task_t, iit_allocation);
        task_importance_update_owner_info(task);
#endif
        ipc_importance_unlock();

        return task_elem;
}

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
void task_importance_update_owner_info(task_t task) {

        if (task != TASK_NULL && task->task_imp_base != IIT_NULL) {
                ipc_importance_task_t task_elem = task->task_imp_base;

                task_elem->iit_bsd_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(task);
                if (task->bsd_info) {
                        strncpy(&task_elem->iit_procname[0], proc_name_address(task->bsd_info), 16);
                        task_elem->iit_procname[16] = '\0';
                } else {
                        strncpy(&task_elem->iit_procname[0], "unknown", 16);
                }
        }
}
#endif

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_reset_locked
 *      Purpose:
 *              Reset a task's IPC importance (the task is going away or exec'ing)
 *
 *              Remove the donor bit and legacy externalized assertions from the
 *              current task importance and see if that wipes out downstream donations.
 *      Conditions:
 *              importance lock held.
 */

static void
ipc_importance_reset_locked(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t donor)
{
        boolean_t before_donor, after_donor;

        /* remove the donor bit, live-donor bit and externalized boosts */
        before_donor = ipc_importance_task_is_donor(task_imp);
        if (donor) {
                task_imp->iit_donor = 0;
        }
        assert(IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) <= IIT_EXTERN(task_imp));
        assert(task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt <= task_imp->iit_externcnt);
        assert(task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop <= task_imp->iit_externdrop);
        task_imp->iit_externcnt -= task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt;
        task_imp->iit_externdrop -= task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop;

        /* assert(IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) <= task_imp->iit_assertcnt); */
        if (IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) < task_imp->iit_assertcnt) {
                task_imp->iit_assertcnt -= IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp);
        } else {
                assert(IIT_LEGACY_EXTERN(task_imp) == task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
                task_imp->iit_assertcnt = 0;
        }
        task_imp->iit_legacy_externcnt = 0;
        task_imp->iit_legacy_externdrop = 0;
        after_donor = ipc_importance_task_is_donor(task_imp);

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
        if (task_imp->iit_assertcnt > 0 && task_imp->iit_live_donor) {
                printf("Live donor task %s[%d] still has %d importance assertions after reset\n", 
                       task_imp->iit_procname, task_imp->iit_bsd_pid, task_imp->iit_assertcnt);
        }
#endif

        /* propagate a downstream drop if there was a change in donor status */
        if (after_donor != before_donor) {
                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(task_imp, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, FALSE);
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_reset
 *      Purpose:
 *              Reset a task's IPC importance
 *
 *              The task is being reset, although staying around. Arrange to have the
 *              external state of the task reset from the importance.
 *      Conditions:
 *              importance lock not held.
 */

void
ipc_importance_reset(ipc_importance_task_t task_imp, boolean_t donor)
{
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                return;
        }
        ipc_importance_lock();
        ipc_importance_reset_locked(task_imp, donor);
        ipc_importance_unlock();
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_disconnect_task
 *      Purpose:
 *              Disconnect a task from its importance.
 *
 *              Clear the task pointer from the importance and drop the
 *              reference the task held on the importance object.  Before
 *              doing that, reset the effects the current task holds on
 *              the importance and see if that wipes out downstream donations.
 *
 *              We allow the upstream boosts to continue to affect downstream
 *              even though the local task is being effectively pulled from
 *              the chain.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked.
 */
void
ipc_importance_disconnect_task(task_t task)
{
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;

        task_lock(task);
        ipc_importance_lock();
        task_imp = task->task_imp_base;

        /* did somebody beat us to it? */
        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                task_unlock(task);
                return;
        }

        /* disconnect the task from this importance */
        assert(task_imp->iit_task == task);
        task_imp->iit_task = TASK_NULL;
        task->task_imp_base = IIT_NULL;
        task_unlock(task);
        
        /* reset the effects the current task hold on the importance */
        ipc_importance_reset_locked(task_imp, TRUE);

        ipc_importance_task_release_locked(task_imp);
        /* importance unlocked */

        /* deallocate the task now that the importance is unlocked */
        task_deallocate(task);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_send
 *      Purpose:
 *              Post the importance voucher attribute [if sent] or a static
 *              importance boost depending upon options and conditions.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Destination port locked on entry and exit, may be dropped during the call.
 *      Returns:
 *              A boolean identifying if the port lock was tempoarily dropped.
 */
boolean_t
ipc_importance_send(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg,
        mach_msg_option_t       option)
{
        ipc_port_t port = (ipc_port_t) kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_remote_port;
        boolean_t port_lock_dropped = FALSE;
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;
        task_t task;
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;
        kern_return_t kr;


        assert(IP_VALID(port));

        /* If no donation to be made, return quickly */
        if ((port->ip_impdonation == 0) ||
            (option & MACH_SEND_NOIMPORTANCE) != 0) {
                return port_lock_dropped;
        }

        task = current_task();

        /* If forced sending a static boost, go update the port */
        if ((option & MACH_SEND_IMPORTANCE) != 0) {
                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits |= MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                goto portupdate;
        }

        task_imp = task->task_imp_base;
        assert(IIT_NULL != task_imp);

        /* If the sender can never donate importance, nothing to do */
        if (ipc_importance_task_is_never_donor(task_imp)) {
                return port_lock_dropped;
        }

        elem = IIE_NULL;

        /* If importance receiver and passing a voucher, look for importance in there */
        if (IP_VALID(kmsg->ikm_voucher) &&
            ipc_importance_task_is_marked_receiver(task_imp)) {
                mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t vals[MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_VALUE_MAX_NESTED];
                mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_size_t val_count;
                ipc_voucher_t voucher;
                        
                assert(ip_kotype(kmsg->ikm_voucher) == IKOT_VOUCHER);
                voucher = (ipc_voucher_t)kmsg->ikm_voucher->ip_kobject;

                /* check to see if the voucher has an importance attribute */
                val_count = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_VALUE_MAX_NESTED;
                kr = mach_voucher_attr_control_get_values(ipc_importance_control, voucher,
                                                          vals, &val_count);
                assert(KERN_SUCCESS == kr);

                /*
                 * Only use importance associated with our task (either directly
                 * or through an inherit that donates to our task).
                 */
                if (0 < val_count) {
                        ipc_importance_elem_t check_elem;

                        check_elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)vals[0];
                        assert(IIE_NULL != check_elem);
                        if (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(check_elem)) {
                                ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit;
                                inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t) check_elem;
                                if (inherit->iii_to_task == task_imp) {
                                        elem = check_elem;
                                }
                        } else if (check_elem == (ipc_importance_elem_t)task_imp) {
                                elem = check_elem;
                        }
                }
        }

        /* If we haven't found an importance attribute to send yet, use the task's */
        if (IIE_NULL == elem) {
                elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)task_imp;
        }

        /* take a reference for the message to hold */
        ipc_importance_reference_internal(elem);

        /* acquire the importance lock while trying to hang on to port lock */
        if (!ipc_importance_lock_try()) {
                port_lock_dropped = TRUE;
                ip_unlock(port);
                ipc_importance_lock();
        }

        /* link kmsg onto the donor element propagation chain */
        ipc_importance_kmsg_link(kmsg, elem);
        /* elem reference transfered to kmsg */

        incr_ref_counter(elem->iie_kmsg_refs_added);

        /* If the sender isn't currently a donor, no need to apply boost */
        if (!ipc_importance_task_is_donor(task_imp)) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();

                /* re-acquire port lock, if needed */
                if (TRUE == port_lock_dropped)
                        ip_lock(port);

                return port_lock_dropped;
        }

        /* Mark the fact that we are (currently) donating through this message */
        kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits |= MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;

        /*
         * If we need to relock the port, do it with the importance still locked.
         * This assures we get to add the importance boost through the port to
         * the task BEFORE anyone else can attempt to undo that operation because
         * the sender lost donor status.
         */
        if (TRUE == port_lock_dropped) {
                ip_lock(port);
        }
        ipc_importance_unlock();

 portupdate:
                                
#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        if (kdebug_enable) {
                mach_msg_max_trailer_t *dbgtrailer = (mach_msg_max_trailer_t *)
                                ((vm_offset_t)kmsg->ikm_header + round_msg(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_size));
                unsigned int sender_pid = dbgtrailer->msgh_audit.val[5];
                mach_msg_id_t imp_msgh_id = kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_id;
                KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_MSG, IMP_MSG_SEND)) | DBG_FUNC_START,
                                           audit_token_pid_from_task(task), sender_pid, imp_msgh_id, 0, 0);
        }
#endif /* IMPORTANCE_DEBUG */

        /* adjust port boost count (with port locked) */
        if (TRUE == ipc_port_importance_delta(port, 1)) {
                port_lock_dropped = TRUE;
                ip_lock(port);
        }
        return port_lock_dropped;
}
        
/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_inherit_from
 *      Purpose:
 *              Create a "made" reference for an importance attribute representing
 *              an inheritance between the sender of a message (if linked) and the
 *              current task importance.  If the message is not linked, a static
 *              boost may be created, based on the boost state of the message.
 *
 *              Any transfer from kmsg linkage to inherit linkage must be atomic.
 *
 *              If the task is inactive, there isn't any need to return a new reference.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
static ipc_importance_inherit_t
ipc_importance_inherit_from(ipc_kmsg_t kmsg)
{
        ipc_importance_task_t   task_imp = IIT_NULL;
        ipc_importance_elem_t   from_elem = kmsg->ikm_importance;
        ipc_importance_elem_t   elem;
        task_t  task_self = current_task();

        ipc_port_t port = kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_remote_port;
        ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit = III_NULL;
        ipc_importance_inherit_t alloc = III_NULL;
        ipc_importance_inherit_t temp_inherit;
        boolean_t cleared_self_donation = FALSE;
        boolean_t donating;
        uint32_t depth = 1;

        /* The kmsg must have an importance donor or static boost to proceed */
        if (IIE_NULL == kmsg->ikm_importance &&
            !MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits)) {
                return III_NULL;
        }

        /* 
         * No need to set up an inherit linkage if the dest isn't a receiver
         * of one type or the other.
         */
        if (!ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(task_self->task_imp_base)) {
                ipc_importance_lock();
                goto out_locked;
        }

        /* Grab a reference on the importance of the destination */
        task_imp = ipc_importance_for_task(task_self, FALSE);

        ipc_importance_lock();

        if (IIT_NULL == task_imp) {
                goto out_locked;
        }

        incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_added_inherit_from);

        /* If message is already associated with an inherit... */
        if (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(from_elem)) {
                ipc_importance_inherit_t from_inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)from_elem;

                /* already targeting our task? - just use it */
                if (from_inherit->iii_to_task == task_imp) {
                        /* clear self-donation if not also present in inherit */
                        if (!from_inherit->iii_donating &&
                            MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits)) {
                                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                                cleared_self_donation = TRUE;
                        }
                        inherit = from_inherit;
                                
                } else if (III_DEPTH_MAX == III_DEPTH(from_inherit)) {
                        ipc_importance_task_t to_task;
                        ipc_importance_elem_t unlinked_from;

                        /*
                         * Chain too long. Switch to looking
                         * directly at the from_inherit's to-task
                         * as our source of importance. 
                         */
                        to_task = from_inherit->iii_to_task;
                        ipc_importance_task_reference(to_task);
                        from_elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)to_task;
                        depth = III_DEPTH_RESET | 1;

                        /* Fixup the kmsg linkage to reflect change */
                        unlinked_from = ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink(kmsg);
                        assert(unlinked_from == (ipc_importance_elem_t)from_inherit);
                        ipc_importance_kmsg_link(kmsg, from_elem);
                        ipc_importance_inherit_release_locked(from_inherit);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                        ipc_importance_lock();

                } else {
                        /* inheriting from an inherit */
                        depth = from_inherit->iii_depth + 1;
                }
        } 

        /* 
         * Don't allow a task to inherit from itself (would keep it permanently
         * boosted even if all other donors to the task went away).
         */

        if (from_elem == (ipc_importance_elem_t)task_imp) {
                goto out_locked;
        }

        /* 
         * But if the message isn't associated with any linked source, it is
         * intended to be permanently boosting (static boost from kernel).
         * In that case DO let the process permanently boost itself.
         */
        if (IIE_NULL == from_elem) {
                assert(MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits));
                ipc_importance_task_reference_internal(task_imp);
                from_elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)task_imp;
        }
        
        /* 
         * Now that we have the from_elem figured out,
         * check to see if we already have an inherit for this pairing
         */
        while (III_NULL == inherit) {
                queue_iterate(&from_elem->iie_inherits, temp_inherit,
                              ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance) {
                        if (temp_inherit->iii_to_task == task_imp &&
                            temp_inherit->iii_depth == depth) {
                                inherit = temp_inherit;
                                break;
                        }
                }

                /* Do we have to allocate a new inherit */
                if (III_NULL == inherit) {
                        if (III_NULL != alloc) {
                                break;
                        }

                        /* allocate space */
                        ipc_importance_unlock();
                        alloc = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)
                                zalloc(ipc_importance_inherit_zone);
                        ipc_importance_lock();
                }
        }

        /* snapshot the donating status while we have importance locked */
        donating = MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits);

        if (III_NULL != inherit) {
                /* We found one, piggyback on that */
                assert(0 < III_REFS(inherit));
                assert(0 < IIE_REFS(inherit->iii_from_elem));
                assert(inherit->iii_externcnt >= inherit->iii_made);

                /* add in a made reference */
                if (0 == inherit->iii_made++) {
                        assert(III_REFS_MAX > III_REFS(inherit));
                        ipc_importance_inherit_reference_internal(inherit);
                }

                /* Reflect the inherit's change of status into the task boosts */
                if (0 == III_EXTERN(inherit)) {
                        assert(!inherit->iii_donating);
                        inherit->iii_donating = donating;
                        if (donating) {
                                task_imp->iit_externcnt += inherit->iii_externcnt;
                                task_imp->iit_externdrop += inherit->iii_externdrop;
                        }
                } else {
                        assert(donating == inherit->iii_donating);
                }

                /* add in a external reference for this use of the inherit */
                inherit->iii_externcnt++;
                if (donating) {
                        task_imp->iit_externcnt++;
                }
        } else {
                /* initialize the previously allocated space */
                inherit = alloc;
                inherit->iii_bits = IIE_TYPE_INHERIT | 1;
                inherit->iii_made = 1;
                inherit->iii_externcnt = 1;
                inherit->iii_externdrop = 0;
                inherit->iii_depth = depth;
                inherit->iii_to_task = task_imp;
                inherit->iii_from_elem = IIE_NULL;
                queue_init(&inherit->iii_kmsgs);
                queue_init(&inherit->iii_inherits);

                /* If donating, reflect that in the task externcnt */
                if (donating) {
                        inherit->iii_donating = TRUE;
                        task_imp->iit_externcnt++;
                } else {
                        inherit->iii_donating = FALSE;
                }

                /*
                 * Chain our new inherit on the element it inherits from.
                 * The new inherit takes our reference on from_elem.
                 */
                ipc_importance_inherit_link(inherit, from_elem);

#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
                ipc_importance_counter_init(&inherit->iii_elem);
                from_elem->iie_kmsg_refs_inherited++;
                task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_inherited++;
#endif
        }

 out_locked:
        /* 
         * for those paths that came straight here: snapshot the donating status
         * (this should match previous snapshot for other paths).
         */
        donating = MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits);

        /* unlink the kmsg inheritance (if any) */
        elem = ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink(kmsg);
        assert(elem == from_elem);

        /* If we didn't create a new inherit, we have some resources to release */
        if (III_NULL == inherit || inherit != alloc) {
                if (IIE_NULL != from_elem) {
                        if (III_NULL != inherit) {
                                incr_ref_counter(from_elem->iie_kmsg_refs_coalesced);
                        } else {
                                incr_ref_counter(from_elem->iie_kmsg_refs_dropped);
                        }
                        ipc_importance_release_locked(from_elem);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                } else {
                        ipc_importance_unlock();
                }

                if (IIT_NULL != task_imp) {
                        if (III_NULL != inherit) {
                                incr_ref_counter(task_imp->iit_elem.iie_task_refs_coalesced);
                        }
                        ipc_importance_task_release(task_imp);
                }

                if (III_NULL != alloc)
                        zfree(ipc_importance_inherit_zone, alloc);
        } else {
                /* from_elem and task_imp references transferred to new inherit */
                ipc_importance_unlock();
        }

        /* decrement port boost count */ 
        if (donating) {
                ip_lock(port);
                if (III_NULL != inherit) {
                        /* task assertions transferred to inherit, just adjust port count */
                        ipc_port_impcount_delta(port, -1, IP_NULL);
                        ip_unlock(port);
                }  else {
                        /* drop importance from port and destination task */
                        if (ipc_port_importance_delta(port, -1) == FALSE) {
                                ip_unlock(port);
                        }
                }
        } else if (cleared_self_donation) {
                ip_lock(port);
                /* drop cleared donation from port and destination task */
                if (ipc_port_importance_delta(port, -1) == FALSE) {
                        ip_unlock(port);
                }
        }

        if (III_NULL != inherit) {
                /* have an associated importance attr, even if currently not donating */
                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits |= MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
        } else {
                /* we won't have an importance attribute associated with our message */
                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
        }

        return inherit;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_receive
 *      Purpose:
 *              Process importance attributes in a received message.
 *
 *              If an importance voucher attribute was sent, transform
 *              that into an attribute value reflecting the inheritance
 *              from the sender to the receiver.
 *
 *              If a static boost is received (or the voucher isn't on
 *              a voucher-based boost), export a static boost.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked.
 */
void
ipc_importance_receive(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg,
        mach_msg_option_t       option)
{
        unsigned int sender_pid = ((mach_msg_max_trailer_t *)
                                   ((vm_offset_t)kmsg->ikm_header + 
                                    round_msg(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_size)))->msgh_audit.val[5];
        task_t task_self = current_task();
        int impresult = -1;
        
        /* convert to a voucher with an inherit importance attribute? */
        if ((option & MACH_RCV_VOUCHER) != 0) {
                uint8_t recipes[2 * sizeof(ipc_voucher_attr_recipe_data_t) + 
                                sizeof(mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t)];
                ipc_voucher_attr_raw_recipe_array_size_t recipe_size = 0;
                ipc_voucher_attr_recipe_t recipe = (ipc_voucher_attr_recipe_t)recipes;
                        ipc_voucher_t recv_voucher;
                mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t handle;
                ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit;
                kern_return_t kr;

                /* set up recipe to copy the old voucher */
                if (IP_VALID(kmsg->ikm_voucher)) {
                        ipc_voucher_t sent_voucher = (ipc_voucher_t)kmsg->ikm_voucher->ip_kobject;

                        recipe->key = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_KEY_ALL;
                        recipe->command = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_COPY;
                        recipe->previous_voucher = sent_voucher;
                        recipe->content_size = 0;
                        recipe_size += sizeof(*recipe);
                }

                /*
                 * create an inheritance attribute from the kmsg (may be NULL)
                 * transferring any boosts from the kmsg linkage through the
                 * port directly to the new inheritance object.
                 */
                inherit = ipc_importance_inherit_from(kmsg);
                handle = (mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t)inherit;

                assert(IIE_NULL == kmsg->ikm_importance);

                /* replace the importance attribute with the handle we created */
                /*  our made reference on the inhert is donated to the voucher */
                recipe = (ipc_voucher_attr_recipe_t)&recipes[recipe_size];
                recipe->key = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_KEY_IMPORTANCE;
                recipe->command = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_SET_VALUE_HANDLE;
                recipe->previous_voucher = IPC_VOUCHER_NULL;
                recipe->content_size = sizeof(mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t);
                *(mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t *)(void *)recipe->content = handle;
                recipe_size += sizeof(*recipe) + sizeof(mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t);

                kr = ipc_voucher_attr_control_create_mach_voucher(ipc_importance_control,
                                                                  recipes,
                                                                  recipe_size,
                                                                  &recv_voucher);
                assert(KERN_SUCCESS == kr);

                /* swap the voucher port (and set voucher bits in case it didn't already exist) */
                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits |= (MACH_MSG_TYPE_MOVE_SEND << 16);
                ipc_port_release_send(kmsg->ikm_voucher);
                kmsg->ikm_voucher = convert_voucher_to_port(recv_voucher);
                if (III_NULL != inherit)
                        impresult = 2;

        } else { /* Don't want a voucher */

                /* got linked importance? have to drop */
                if (IIE_NULL != kmsg->ikm_importance) {
                        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;

                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        elem = ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink(kmsg);
#if IIE_REF_DEBUG
                        elem->iie_kmsg_refs_dropped++;
#endif
                        ipc_importance_release_locked(elem);
                        /* importance unlocked */
                }

                /* With kmsg unlinked, can safely examine message importance attribute. */
                if (MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits)) {
                        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp = task_self->task_imp_base;
                        ipc_port_t port = kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_remote_port;

                        /* defensive deduction for release builds lacking the assert */
                        ip_lock(port);
                        ipc_port_impcount_delta(port, -1, IP_NULL);
                        ip_unlock(port);

                        /* will user accept legacy responsibility for the importance boost */
                        if (KERN_SUCCESS == ipc_importance_task_externalize_legacy_assertion(task_imp, 1, sender_pid)) {
                                impresult = 1;
                        } else {
                                /* The importance boost never applied to task (clear the bit) */
                                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                                impresult = 0;
                        }
                }
        }

#if IMPORTANCE_DEBUG
        if (-1 < impresult)
                KERNEL_DEBUG_CONSTANT_IST(KDEBUG_TRACE, (IMPORTANCE_CODE(IMP_MSG, IMP_MSG_DELV)) | DBG_FUNC_NONE,
                                sender_pid, audit_token_pid_from_task(task_self),
                                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_id, impresult, 0);
        if (impresult == 2){
                /*
                 * This probe only covers new voucher-based path.  Legacy importance
                 * will trigger the probe in ipc_importance_task_externalize_assertion() 
                 * above and have impresult==1 here.
                 */
                DTRACE_BOOST5(receive_boost, task_t, task_self, int, audit_token_pid_from_task(task_self), int, sender_pid, int, 1, int, task_self->task_imp_base->iit_assertcnt);
    }
#endif /* IMPORTANCE_DEBUG */
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_unreceive
 *      Purpose:
 *              Undo receive of importance attributes in a message.
 *
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked.
 */
void
ipc_importance_unreceive(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg,
        mach_msg_option_t       __unused option)
{
        /* importance should already be in the voucher and out of the kmsg */
        assert(IIE_NULL == kmsg->ikm_importance);

        /* See if there is a legacy boost to be dropped from receiver */
        if (MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits)) {
                ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;

                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                task_imp = current_task()->task_imp_base;
                if (!IP_VALID(kmsg->ikm_voucher) && IIT_NULL != task_imp) {
                        ipc_importance_task_drop_legacy_external_assertion(task_imp, 1);
                }
                /*
                 * ipc_kmsg_copyout_dest() will consume the voucher
                 * and any contained importance.
                 */
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_clean
 *      Purpose:
 *              Clean up importance state in a kmsg that is being cleaned.
 *              Unlink the importance chain if one was set up, and drop
 *              the reference this kmsg held on the donor.  Then check to
 *              if importance was carried to the port, and remove that if
 *              needed.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked.
 */
void
ipc_importance_clean(
        ipc_kmsg_t              kmsg)
{
        ipc_port_t              port;

        /* Is the kmsg still linked? If so, remove that first */
        if (IIE_NULL != kmsg->ikm_importance) {
                ipc_importance_elem_t   elem;

                ipc_importance_lock();
                elem = ipc_importance_kmsg_unlink(kmsg);
                assert(IIE_NULL != elem);
                ipc_importance_release_locked(elem);
                /* importance unlocked */
        }

        /* See if there is a legacy importance boost to be dropped from port */
        if (MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits)) {
                kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits &= ~MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISEIMP;
                port = kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_remote_port;
                if (IP_VALID(port)) {
                        ip_lock(port);
                        /* inactive ports already had their importance boosts dropped */
                        if (!ip_active(port) || 
                            ipc_port_importance_delta(port, -1) == FALSE) {
                                ip_unlock(port);
                        }
                }
        }
}

void
ipc_importance_assert_clean(__assert_only ipc_kmsg_t kmsg)
{
  assert(IIE_NULL == kmsg->ikm_importance);
  assert(!MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits));
}

/*
 * IPC Importance Attribute Manager definition
 */

static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_release_value(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t              manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                 key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t        value,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_reference_t     sync);

static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_get_value(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t                      manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                         key,
        mach_voucher_attr_recipe_command_t              command,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t          prev_values,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_size_t     prev_value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                content_size,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t                *out_value,
        ipc_voucher_t                                   *out_value_voucher);

static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_extract_content(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t                      manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                         key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t          values,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_size_t     value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_recipe_command_t              *out_command,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     out_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                *in_out_content_size);

static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_command(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t                      manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                         key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t          values,
        mach_msg_type_number_t                          value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_command_t                     command,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     in_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                in_content_size,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     out_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                *out_content_size);

static void
ipc_importance_manager_release(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t              manager);

struct ipc_voucher_attr_manager ipc_importance_manager = {
        .ivam_release_value =   ipc_importance_release_value,
        .ivam_get_value =       ipc_importance_get_value,
        .ivam_extract_content = ipc_importance_extract_content,
        .ivam_command =         ipc_importance_command,
        .ivam_release =         ipc_importance_manager_release,
};

#define IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_KEY(key) assert(MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_KEY_IMPORTANCE == (key))
#define IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager) assert(&ipc_importance_manager == (manager))

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_release_value [Voucher Attribute Manager Interface]
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release what the voucher system believes is the last "made" reference
 *              on an importance attribute value handle.  The sync parameter is used to
 *              avoid races with new made references concurrently being returned to the
 *              voucher system in other threads.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_release_value(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t              __assert_only manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                 __assert_only key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t        value,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_reference_t     sync)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;

        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager);
        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_KEY(key);
        assert(0 < sync);

        elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)value;

        ipc_importance_lock();

        /* Any oustanding made refs? */
        if (sync != elem->iie_made) {
                assert(sync < elem->iie_made);
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return KERN_FAILURE;
        }

        /* clear made */ 
        elem->iie_made = 0;

        /* 
         * If there are pending external boosts represented by this attribute, 
         * drop them from the apropriate task 
         */
        if (IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) {
                ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem;

                assert(inherit->iii_externcnt >= inherit->iii_externdrop);

                if (inherit->iii_donating) {
                        ipc_importance_task_t imp_task = inherit->iii_to_task;
                        uint32_t assertcnt = III_EXTERN(inherit);

                        assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(imp_task));
                        assert(imp_task->iit_externcnt >= inherit->iii_externcnt);
                        assert(imp_task->iit_externdrop >= inherit->iii_externdrop);
                        imp_task->iit_externcnt -= inherit->iii_externcnt;
                        imp_task->iit_externdrop -= inherit->iii_externdrop;
                        inherit->iii_externcnt = 0;
                        inherit->iii_externdrop = 0;
                        inherit->iii_donating = FALSE;

                        /* adjust the internal assertions - and propagate if needed */
                        if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(imp_task, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, assertcnt)) {
                                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(imp_task, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, TRUE);
                        }
                } else {
                        inherit->iii_externcnt = 0;
                        inherit->iii_externdrop = 0;
                }
        } 

        /* drop the made reference on elem */
        ipc_importance_release_locked(elem);
        /* returns unlocked */

        return KERN_SUCCESS;
}


/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_get_value [Voucher Attribute Manager Interface]
 *      Purpose:
 *              Convert command and content data into a reference on a [potentially new]
 *              attribute value.  The importance attribute manager will only allow the
 *              caller to get a value for the current task's importance, or to redeem
 *              an importance attribute from an existing voucher.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_get_value(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t                      __assert_only manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                         __assert_only key,
        mach_voucher_attr_recipe_command_t              command,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t          prev_values,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_size_t     prev_value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     __unused content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                content_size,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t                *out_value,
        ipc_voucher_t                                   *out_value_voucher)
{
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;
        task_t self;

        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager);
        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_KEY(key);

        if (0 != content_size)
                return KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;

        /* never an out voucher */

        switch (command) {

        case MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_REDEEM:

                /* redeem of previous values is the value */
                if (0 < prev_value_count) {
                        elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)prev_values[0];
                        assert(IIE_NULL != elem);

                        ipc_importance_lock();
                        assert(0 < elem->iie_made);
                        elem->iie_made++;
                        ipc_importance_unlock();

                        *out_value = prev_values[0];
                        return KERN_SUCCESS;
                }

                /* redeem of default is default */
                *out_value = 0;
                *out_value_voucher = IPC_VOUCHER_NULL;
                return KERN_SUCCESS;

        case MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_IMPORTANCE_SELF:
                self = current_task();

                elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)ipc_importance_for_task(self, TRUE);
                /* made reference added (or IIE_NULL which isn't referenced) */

                *out_value = (mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t)elem;
                *out_value_voucher = IPC_VOUCHER_NULL;
                return KERN_SUCCESS;
                
        default:
                /* 
                 * every other command is unknown
                 *
                 * Specifically, there is no mechanism provided to construct an
                 * importance attribute for a task/process from just a pid or
                 * task port.  It has to be copied (or redeemed) from a previous
                 * voucher that has it.
                 */
                return KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;
        }
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_extract_content [Voucher Attribute Manager Interface]
 *      Purpose:
 *              Extract meaning from the attribute value present in a voucher.  While
 *              the real goal is to provide commands and data that can reproduce the
 *              voucher's value "out of thin air", this isn't possible with importance
 *              attribute values.  Instead, return debug info to help track down dependencies.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_extract_content(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t                      __assert_only manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                         __assert_only key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t          values,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_size_t     value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_recipe_command_t              *out_command,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t                     out_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t                *in_out_content_size)
{
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t size = 0;
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;
        unsigned int i;

        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager);
        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_KEY(key);

        /* the first non-default value provides the data */
        for (i = 0; i < value_count ; i++) {
                elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)values[i];
                if (IIE_NULL == elem)
                        continue;

                snprintf((char *)out_content, *in_out_content_size, "Importance for pid ");
                size = (mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t)strlen((char *)out_content);

                for(;;) {
                        ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit = III_NULL;
                        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp;
                        task_t task;
                        int task_pid;

                        if (IIE_TYPE_TASK == IIE_TYPE(elem)) {
                                task_imp = (ipc_importance_task_t)elem;
                                task = task_imp->iit_task;
                                task_pid = (TASK_NULL != task) ?
                                           audit_token_pid_from_task(task) : -1;
                                snprintf((char *)out_content + size, *in_out_content_size - size, "%d", task_pid);
                        } else {
                                inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem;
                                task_imp = inherit->iii_to_task;
                                task = task_imp->iit_task;
                                task_pid = (TASK_NULL != task) ?
                                           audit_token_pid_from_task(task) : -1;
                                snprintf((char *)out_content + size, *in_out_content_size - size, 
                                         "%d (%d of %d boosts) %s from pid ", task_pid,
                                         III_EXTERN(inherit), inherit->iii_externcnt, 
                                         (inherit->iii_donating) ? "donated" : "linked");
                        }
                        
                        size = (mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t)strlen((char *)out_content);

                        if (III_NULL == inherit)
                                break;

                        elem = inherit->iii_from_elem;
                }
                size++; /* account for NULL */
        }
        *out_command = MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_NOOP; /* cannot be used to regenerate value */
        *in_out_content_size = size;
        return KERN_SUCCESS;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_command [Voucher Attribute Manager Interface]
 *      Purpose:
 *              Run commands against the importance attribute value found in a voucher.
 *              No such commands are currently supported.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Nothing locked on entry.  May block.
 */
static kern_return_t
ipc_importance_command(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t              __assert_only manager,
        mach_voucher_attr_key_t                 __assert_only key,
        mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_array_t  values,
        mach_msg_type_number_t                  value_count,
        mach_voucher_attr_command_t             command,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t             in_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t        in_content_size,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_t             out_content,
        mach_voucher_attr_content_size_t        *out_content_size)
{
        ipc_importance_inherit_t inherit;
        ipc_importance_task_t to_task;
        uint32_t refs, *outrefsp;
        mach_msg_type_number_t i;
        uint32_t externcnt;

        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager);
        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_KEY(key);

        if (in_content_size != sizeof(refs) ||
            (*out_content_size != 0 && *out_content_size != sizeof(refs))) {
                return KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;
        }
        refs = *(uint32_t *)(void *)in_content;
        outrefsp = (*out_content_size != 0) ? (uint32_t *)(void *)out_content : NULL;

        if (MACH_VOUCHER_IMPORTANCE_ATTR_DROP_EXTERNAL != command) {
                return KERN_NOT_SUPPORTED;
        }

        /* the first non-default value of the apropos type provides the data */
        inherit = III_NULL;
        for (i = 0; i < value_count; i++) {
                ipc_importance_elem_t elem = (ipc_importance_elem_t)values[i];

                if (IIE_NULL != elem && IIE_TYPE_INHERIT == IIE_TYPE(elem)) {
                        inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem;
                        break;
                }
        }
        if (III_NULL == inherit) {
                return KERN_INVALID_ARGUMENT;
        }
                
        ipc_importance_lock();

        if (0 == refs) {
                if (NULL != outrefsp) {
                        *outrefsp = III_EXTERN(inherit);
                }
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return KERN_SUCCESS;
        }

        /* Enough external references left to drop? */
        if (III_EXTERN(inherit) < refs) {
                ipc_importance_unlock();
                return KERN_FAILURE;
        }

        to_task = inherit->iii_to_task;
        assert(ipc_importance_task_is_any_receiver_type(to_task));

        /* re-base external and internal counters at the inherit and the to-task (if apropos) */
        if (inherit->iii_donating) {
                assert(IIT_EXTERN(to_task) >= III_EXTERN(inherit));
                assert(to_task->iit_externcnt >= inherit->iii_externcnt);
                assert(to_task->iit_externdrop >= inherit->iii_externdrop);
                inherit->iii_externdrop += refs;
                to_task->iit_externdrop += refs;
                externcnt = III_EXTERN(inherit);
                if (0 == externcnt) {
                        inherit->iii_donating = FALSE;
                        to_task->iit_externcnt -= inherit->iii_externcnt;
                        to_task->iit_externdrop -= inherit->iii_externdrop;


                        /* Start AppNap delay hysteresis - even if not the last boost for the task. */
                        if (ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call != NULL &&
                            ipc_importance_task_is_marked_denap_receiver(to_task)) {
                                ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop(to_task);
                        } 

                        /* drop task assertions associated with the dropped boosts */
                        if (ipc_importance_task_check_transition(to_task, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, refs)) {
                                ipc_importance_task_propagate_assertion_locked(to_task, IIT_UPDATE_DROP, TRUE);
                                /* may have dropped and retaken importance lock */
                        }
                } else {
                        /* assert(to_task->iit_assertcnt >= refs + externcnt); */
                        /* defensive deduction in case of assertcnt underflow */
                        if (to_task->iit_assertcnt > refs + externcnt) {
                                to_task->iit_assertcnt -= refs;
                        } else {
                                to_task->iit_assertcnt = externcnt;
                        }
                }
        } else {
                inherit->iii_externdrop += refs;
                externcnt = III_EXTERN(inherit);
        }

        /* capture result (if requested) */
        if (NULL != outrefsp) {
                *outrefsp = externcnt;
        }

        ipc_importance_unlock();
        return KERN_SUCCESS;
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_manager_release [Voucher Attribute Manager Interface]
 *      Purpose:
 *              Release the Voucher system's reference on the IPC importance attribute
 *              manager.
 *      Conditions:
 *              As this can only occur after the manager drops the Attribute control
 *              reference granted back at registration time, and that reference is never
 *              dropped, this should never be called.
 */
static void
ipc_importance_manager_release(
        ipc_voucher_attr_manager_t              __assert_only manager)
{
        IMPORTANCE_ASSERT_MANAGER(manager);
        panic("Voucher importance manager released");
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_init
 *      Purpose:
 *              Initialize the  IPC importance manager.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Zones and Vouchers are already initialized.
 */
void
ipc_importance_init(void)
{
        natural_t ipc_importance_max = (task_max + thread_max) * 2;
        char temp_buf[26];
        kern_return_t kr;

        if (PE_parse_boot_argn("imp_interactive_receiver", temp_buf, sizeof(temp_buf))) {
                ipc_importance_interactive_receiver = TRUE;
        }

        ipc_importance_task_zone = zinit(sizeof(struct ipc_importance_task),
                                         ipc_importance_max * sizeof(struct ipc_importance_task),
                                         sizeof(struct ipc_importance_task),
                                         "ipc task importance");
        zone_change(ipc_importance_task_zone, Z_NOENCRYPT, TRUE);

        ipc_importance_inherit_zone = zinit(sizeof(struct ipc_importance_inherit),
                                            ipc_importance_max * sizeof(struct ipc_importance_inherit),
                                            sizeof(struct ipc_importance_inherit),
                                            "ipc importance inherit");
        zone_change(ipc_importance_inherit_zone, Z_NOENCRYPT, TRUE);


#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG 
        queue_init(&global_iit_alloc_queue);
#endif

        /* initialize global locking */
        ipc_importance_lock_init();

        kr = ipc_register_well_known_mach_voucher_attr_manager(&ipc_importance_manager,
                                                (mach_voucher_attr_value_handle_t)0,
                                                MACH_VOUCHER_ATTR_KEY_IMPORTANCE,
                                                &ipc_importance_control);
        if (KERN_SUCCESS != kr)
                printf("Voucher importance manager register returned %d", kr);
}

/*
 *      Routine:        ipc_importance_thread_call_init
 *      Purpose:
 *              Initialize the IPC importance code dependent upon
 *              thread-call support being available.
 *      Conditions:
 *              Thread-call mechanism is already initialized.
 */
void
ipc_importance_thread_call_init(void)
{
        /* initialize delayed drop queue and thread-call */
        queue_init(&ipc_importance_delayed_drop_queue);
        ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call = 
                thread_call_allocate(ipc_importance_task_delayed_drop_scan, NULL);
        if (NULL == ipc_importance_delayed_drop_call) {
                panic("ipc_importance_init");
        }
}

/*
 * Routing: task_importance_list_pids
 * Purpose: list pids where task in donating importance.
 * Conditions: To be called only from kdp stackshot code.
 *             Will panic the system otherwise.
 */
extern int
task_importance_list_pids(task_t task, int flags, int *pid_list, unsigned int max_count)
{
        if (lck_spin_is_acquired(&ipc_importance_lock_data) ||
              max_count < 1 ||
              task->task_imp_base == IIT_NULL ||
              pid_list == NULL ||
              flags != TASK_IMP_LIST_DONATING_PIDS) {
                return 0;
        }
        unsigned int pidcount = 0;
        task_t temp_task;
        ipc_importance_task_t task_imp = task->task_imp_base;
        ipc_kmsg_t temp_kmsg;
        ipc_importance_inherit_t temp_inherit;
        ipc_importance_elem_t elem;
        int target_pid;

        queue_iterate(&task_imp->iit_inherits, temp_inherit, ipc_importance_inherit_t, iii_inheritance) {
                /* check space in buffer */
                if (pidcount >= max_count) 
                        break;
                target_pid = -1;

                if (temp_inherit->iii_donating) {

#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
                        target_pid = temp_inherit->iii_to_task->iit_bsd_pid;
#else
                        temp_task = temp_inherit->iii_to_task->iit_task;
                        if (temp_task != TASK_NULL) {
                                target_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(temp_task);
                        }
#endif
                }

                if (target_pid != -1) {
                        pid_list[pidcount++] = target_pid;
                }

        }

        queue_iterate(&task_imp->iit_kmsgs, temp_kmsg, ipc_kmsg_t, ikm_inheritance) {
                if (pidcount >= max_count)
                        break;
                target_pid = -1;
                elem = temp_kmsg->ikm_importance;
                temp_task = TASK_NULL;

                if (elem == IIE_NULL) {
                        continue;
                }

                if (!(temp_kmsg->ikm_header && MACH_MSGH_BITS_RAISED_IMPORTANCE(temp_kmsg->ikm_header->msgh_bits))) {
                        continue;
                }

                if (IIE_TYPE_TASK == IIE_TYPE(elem) && 
                        (((ipc_importance_task_t)elem)->iit_task != TASK_NULL)) {
                        target_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(((ipc_importance_task_t)elem)->iit_task);
                } else {
                        temp_inherit = (ipc_importance_inherit_t)elem;
#if DEVELOPMENT || DEBUG
                        target_pid = temp_inherit->iii_to_task->iit_bsd_pid;
#else
                        temp_task = temp_inherit->iii_to_task->iit_task;
                        if (temp_task != TASK_NULL) {
                                target_pid = audit_token_pid_from_task(temp_task);
                        }
#endif
                }

                if (target_pid != -1) {
                        pid_list[pidcount++] = target_pid;
                }
        }

        return pidcount;
}